You sit on the edge of your chair, distracted by a photo on his desk; a boy and a girl, aged nine, or thereabouts – about the same age as your daughter, dressed in bright red sweatshirts. Eloise’s birth had been ‘a piece of cake’ from start to finish, thank goodness; refugees, as both of you were, of one brief, failed marriage apiece. A companion for Eloise – what you desperately wanted...but it just never happened. Time was running short – both of you not getting any younger; wasn’t that a fact? The premise she should be an only child, was unthinkable. Didn’t you always have two of everything – two cats, two goldfish...two rabbits? The years went by though, and your hopes dwindled.
“Probably for the best,” friends and family concluded. “How could you contemplate starting all over again; nappies...sleepless nights?” they asked. “You’d be practically drawing your pension, before he or she had even left school. Can you imagine that?”
Oh, but you could. You’ve thought of nothing else for ten years or so; even considered fertility treatment, except Robin was less than enthusiastic.
“Let nature take its course,” he’d said. And it did; finally. You are expecting your second child. You wanted to tell the world; the universe no less...until a visit to the ante-natal clinic, when your worst fears were confirmed.
“Well then, Mr. and Mrs. Daniels, I have to say I am so dreadfully sorry. One in every hundred babies born to woman between the ages of forty and forty-five has Down’s Syndrome; something I believe you were already aware of. I hasten to add though, often, as would seem to be the case here, the desire for a child far outweighs any such risk. Looking again at the same set of statistics, ninety-nine babies out of a hundred are entirely ‘normal’, so I can fully understand your former optimism. However... no matter what the outcome of this pregnancy, feelings of guilt can be an overwhelming emotion at this difficult time, and would remind you of our excellent counselling service which would be at your disposal.
You tell them, ‘Yes’, you were fully aware of the facts and had no intention of going on a guilt trip – your feet, firmly planted on terra firma. Like hell they were. You were terrified, if the truth be known, and you did blame yourself. After all, what had it become, in the end? A race to beat the menopause – prove your fertility, your womanhood; not content with the perfection you already had in Eloise.
And so you nod – condescendingly smile in conditioned response, when they inform you your baby has what is known as the ‘Mosaic’ type of Down’s syndrome; one of the ‘more fortunate’ two percent, which tends to result in milder features than other forms. In conclusion, they say, in case you were wondering, that the amniocentesis result proved the condition definitively. There was no mistake, no margin of error. They ask if you would like to know your unborn child’s sex.
“No,” you say, in unison.
You bite your lip; glance across at Robin. He picks the quick of his thumbnail; glances at you.
You ask them what the next step is...pre-empting their answer. It’s time to make the decision as to whether or not you want the baby; ‘or not’, simply meant opting for an abortion. Why didn’t they just say it? Absentmindedly, your hand traces the outline of your rounded tummy. Can he hear all this, you wonder? Would he want to be born if he could envisage his future? And even if he did, could you cope? What sort of life would you have? There is no wrong or right decision, they reassure you. Only a question of what is right for you as a family. If you do decide on an abortion they will make all the necessary arrangements and provide you with ‘psychological support’...whatever that meant.
They shepherd you to the door...shake your hand and give you a leaflet produced by The Down’s Syndrome Association. You find yourself, of all things, saying, ‘Thank you’.
***
On the way back in the car, the rush-hour traffic is horrendous; Staples Corner at four-thirty in the afternoon.
“Where the hell do we go from here, Robin? Those doctors – what can they possibly know about what we’re going through? So tell me...what do we do? I’m up to here with it all! Why did this happen to us? What have we done so terrible in life to deserve this?
“I know exactly how you feel, love,” he replies. “First up...we’re going home and then let’s talk about it...again. Detest driving around town at this hour – hoards of school kids everywhere. Take that one, for instance; on and off the bloody kerb! Never heard of the Highway Code, I don’t suppose.
Look...Susanna, love...just wanted you to know, I’m OK with whatever you decide. At the end of the day, you are the one who is most affected. Only you can know what the right thing to do is....for all of us.”
The right thing for whom, though? Yourself, Robin, Eloise, the baby...the child...the adolescent...the man – trapped inside a mind and a body he’ll probably despise.
The entire evening you spend glued to the computer, researching Down’s syndrome. What actually is it anyway? You’ve never really known; the kind of thing happens to other people’s families – not yours.
‘Down’s syndrome is a genetic condition known as trisomy, where a person inherits an extra copy of one chromosome, resulting in three copies of chromosome twenty-one, rather than the normal two’, you read out loud from the screen.
What in heaven’s name does ‘chromosome twenty-one’ mean? You read on, hoping to be enlightened.
‘People with Down’s tend to be shorter than average, with poor muscle tone, and have short, broad hands with a single crease across the palm.’
Your hand instinctively rests on your tummy. You look down, turn it palm upwards and try to imagine his. You look back at the screen.
‘Down’s syndrome affects around one in a thousand babies born in the UK, approximately six hundred babies a year, and is the most common cause of learning disability. Most affected children are usually happy, and extremely affectionate however, and some live well into adulthood … There is no cure for Downs … Some need full-time care …’
You wish you could get off this roller-coaster, as a wave of nausea engulfs you; ‘chromosome twenty-one’, still puzzling you, as you finally throw up. In your head, you keep going over old ground. If you do decide to let this pregnancy run its course – have the child, wouldn’t that be selfish? On the other hand, do you have the right to play God? Could you go through with it anyway? You’d always been against abortion, full-stop! You ask yourself why you persist in calling this child a ‘he’? A rhetorical question, though. You know as sure as your desire to become pregnant, this child inside you is a boy, just like you knew Eloise was a girl. Each time you closed your eyes, before she was born, you could see her, in every detail as she is now, the image of you. In the same way you can see him, dark brown, corkscrew hair, the image of his father. Speaking of which, Robin was the proverbial ‘brick’. He couldn’t give a damn whether it was a boy or a girl. Simply wanted it to be fit and healthy; what he said about Eloise before she was born and what he’d said about this one...in the early days.
***
And then there were people in general. Everyone avoids you. Embarrassment, you suppose; hurtful nonetheless. You get used to the fact no one phones for a chat anymore...seeing neighbours crossing to the other side of the street when they catch sight of you. Amazing how quickly bad news spreads.
What Eloise feels about the baby, you’re uncertain. She was over the moon when you first became pregnant; couldn’t wait to have a baby brother or sister, now she changes the subject whenever you bring it up. You’ve noticed she’s even stopped gently patting your tummy, pretending to talk to him. Maybe he could even hear her. In that case he would be missing it too. For the umpteenth time, you remind yourself to stop calling it a ‘he’. ‘It’ is a sixteen week foetus. ‘It’ is devoid of feeling.
You think about the spare-room – the nursery. It’s uncluttered, comparatively empty. You had such visions for it; the cot you’d set your heart on from John Lewis, positioned just beneath the window. Lemon, the walls would be, with lime green curtains. That way it wouldn’t matter whether it was a boy, or a girl.
Downstairs, you hear the phone ring. You jump out of the shower, crack open the bathroom door. Something is wrong; Robin’s voice – so small...like you’ve never heard it before. Towel wrapped around you, you listen.
“I see … I see. When will you know? You must be able to give us some idea, for Christ’s sake! I’m sorry. It’s just… I see. I understand. No … I realise you can’t tell me more; not over the phone. We’re on our way, but before we get there, tell her … tell her Mummy and Daddy will be there very soon and … tell her we love her.”
“My God! Tell me it’s not Eloise. Tell me I’m wrong...please?”
She’d planned to go to a friend’s house after school; some kind of Geography project they were working on. You hear Robin telling you she was crossing the road. You picture it in your mind. The school bus always stops in the same place; right outside the fish and chip shop – double yellow lines, but drivers ignored them, the stupid bastards. You and some other parents had voiced your concerns to the headmaster; always maintained there’d be an accident, one day...
“Your daughter ran out from behind the bus, Mrs. Daniels, straight into the path of an oncoming car. The driver is in custody, so I’m informed, but the police will obviously give you all the details. Apparently, according to witnesses, the offending vehicle appeared to have been travelling quite slowly, but she was simply invisible... until the last,” they tell you at the hospital. “She would seem to have comparatively superficial injuries...grazing to her arms and knees, etc. Except, when she fell, she took a rather nasty blow to her head and it’s this which is giving rise to concern.”
They tell you not to be alarmed at the daunting array of equipment surrounding her. ‘It’s standard procedure; for someone admitted to the high dependency unit, so they can monitor her carefully and maintain necessary fluid intake and so on, whilst she is unconscious.’
You ask, “You mean … she’s on a life-support machine?”
“Yes,” they tell you, “But don’t be unduly concerned. Her condition is ‘stable’, but I have to be honest and say it is early days yet, and the first twenty-four hours, or so, are critical. The thing which really concerns us is the extent of any possible brain damage.”
But you are concerned. Concerned? You are half out of your mind! You try to convince yourself this really is your daughter; head swathed in bandages, tubes and wires invading her body... The same daughter, never tired of ‘Under Plum Lake’, a book she’d always loved; the one you’ve read to her most every bedtime since the year dot. You have it with you now – hastily crammed into your bag before you left home this evening, plus, of course, a somewhat moth-eaten Rupert Bear she would never dream of going to bed without; white fur turned grey, and sadly, missing one ear. A heart monitor bleeps reassuringly at you. You understand its message. At least she is alive. At the most she is alive.
***
‘The first twenty-fours are critical’, their voices echoing round your head. They tell you they may have to operate to alleviate the pressure of the fluid on the brain. There may be some permanent speech or memory loss – impairment of movement. Tell you to ‘prepare yourself’. They say they’re doing all they can. They don’t tell you what you’re supposed to do...
Except, “Try and grab a couple of hours sleep. Along the corridor are a couple of settees you can stretch out on. I totally understand your reticence to leave your daughter’s side, and one of you should be here – should she regain consciousness. It’s important for her to be stimulated by familiar faces and so on, to encourage her brain to start functioning again, normally – give it a kind of kick start.”
You exchange a brief glance, and it’s understood you’ll both sit it out – however long it takes.
You feel a fluttering inside...like a little bird – a sparrow, perhaps, with a broken wing...
“What is it, Susanna?” Robin asks.
“Only the baby; making its presence felt. Here – can you feel?” his hand, warm, reassuring.
“Yes, yes I can; probably fancies himself as David Beckham – poor little blighter. Shit! That was so thoughtless. I keep forgetting it’s only an ‘it’, at the moment.”
“No. It wasn’t your fault, Robin. He is our son...no matter how tiny. Our flesh and blood; the answer to our prayers, and I’m his life-support machine, and I can’t ‘switch it off’ any more than I could Eloise’s…And, David is a good name. Wouldn’t you agree, Eloise?”
“I know it’s late,” you tell her, “way past your bedtime, but maybe just a page or two, before we say goodnight...as a special treat, of course.” You swear she can hear you.
You stroke her hand – so pale, so fragile, so perfect. Again, you visualise his...one single crease along the palm – perfect in its imperfection; much like her Rupert Bear. You marvel at her long, dark eyelashes – move an errant lock of hair, falls across her forehead. You look up at Robin as he buries his face in his hands and quietly sobs. There is no decision to be made, now. Eloise has made it for you. You will go on hoping for the best, because at the end of the day, you can’t hope for more.
You begin to read; you know it by heart. So does she. You reach her favourite part...the passage she has you repeat time upon time. You sense her eyelids flicker, or maybe it’s a cruel trick of the light.
“I want to buy a Ragusa and fly on my kite above *Plum Lake. I want to go to a pleasure-dome and I want to be a fish and want to visit the Abyss, even though I know I’d be scared as Barry. I want to lick a sweet …”
“that turns my mouth into a cathedral,” you can hear her say...you swear you can.
* An extract from ‘Under Plum Lake’ written by Lionel Davidson.

Comments
oldpesky | July 7, 2011 - 16:45
An excellent read. Had me gripped all the way. Eloise being hit by a car reminded me of one of my favourite short stories, Raymond Carver's A Small, Good Thing. Best of luck.
Cavalcaderl | July 7, 2011 - 17:02
new Silver-Spun-Sand
Tina, a very gripping interesting
story, I had to read it all. Sad.
I feel it is true, so much? But not heard
of the Author. Sorry.
Good luck with the competition entries.
julie xx
Silver Spun Sand | July 7, 2011 - 17:32
Thank you, so very much, op. Prose doesn't come easily to me, and your thoughtful words, worth the world.
Tina
Silver Spun Sand | July 7, 2011 - 17:34
Hi there, Julie. I hadn't heard of Lionel Davidson, before I bought 'Under Plum Lake' for my daughter, about thirty years ago now. Since then, it has become a kind of a classic, and it still holds a very special place in her heart...even now.
Thanks for reading and for your kind wishes;-)
Tina xx
kheldar | July 7, 2011 - 17:58
Incredibly moving Tina and so well written - best of luck in the competition!
:--) xxx
Silver Spun Sand | July 7, 2011 - 18:01
Gosh, David...really good to hear from you, and thank you, so very much, for taking the trouble to read this, and for your more than encouraging
words;-)
And the very best of luck to you, David. There are going to be quite a few of us keeping our fingers and toes crossed over the next few weeks, I am sure.
Hope you are well, and I wish you a peaceful evening.
Tina;-)xxx
kheldar | July 7, 2011 - 18:25
I wish the same too you in return!
I won't be doing too much digit crossing, when we ran the 1500 metres at school I considered it a success to get round without being lapped - I entered this competition in much the same spirit !!!
:--) xxx
Silver Spun Sand | July 7, 2011 - 18:41
;-)x
skinner_jennifer | July 7, 2011 - 23:01
Wow! Tina,
this was some pretty moving, emotional piece of
writing. Imagine having to make a decision like
that and then your daughter is on a life support
machine. I just cannot imagine how I would feel.
This was a very well written story and I wish
you all the luck in the world with the competition.
Jenny.
Highhat | July 8, 2011 - 05:27
I can never stop reading your stuff Tina- it is so good and you do it very well as a prosist. Good luck to you. It is exciting to see who gets the prizes indeed.
;)Pia
Silver Spun Sand | July 8, 2011 - 07:56
Thanks, Jenny, for reading and for your lovely comment and good wishes;-)
Tina
Silver Spun Sand | July 8, 2011 - 07:57
It certainly is exciting, Pia;-) Thank you for reading this. I find prose a great challenge, and I'm so pleased you found it at least 'readable';-)
Have a sunny Friday;-)
Tina
insertponceyfre... | July 8, 2011 - 17:40
very moving and well written Tina - and a really good place to end it. Good luck with the competition!
one thing - you have a fish and chop shop - think this must be a typo!!!
Silver Spun Sand | July 8, 2011 - 18:20
What would I do without you, insert...? Mind you, don't you have 'fish and chop' shops, where you are? Seriously though, many thanks for spotting my 'deliberate mistake'...eagle-eyed as ever.
Pleased you enjoyed, and thank you for your good wishes;-)
Tina
rjnewlyn | July 8, 2011 - 22:33
Wow - I don't think I've ever seen prose from you. And you're a natural - really well written, nicely paced, gripping all the way and (as Insert says) ending in the right place. Perhaps it's a calling ...
Good luck with it anyway
Rob
Silver Spun Sand | July 9, 2011 - 07:50
Thanks, so much, Rob. I do find prose a challenge, which is why I always enjoy your stories. You make it look so easy...which indeed it is not;-)
Tina
The Big Bad G | July 13, 2011 - 13:33
/catches up
A thought-provoking place to end indeed. 2nd person narratives are hard to sustain so this is particularly well done given it's a first outing. The chorus voices - 'they' in the hospital, the friends, the phone call etc - give the whole thing a sense of being out of our control and alienated which fits the theme well. Best of luck in the competition. And don't be scared of writing more prose!
Silver Spun Sand | July 13, 2011 - 16:24
Hi there, TBBG;-)
Can't tell you how much your words meant. I'm really glad you picked up on the 2nd person approach. As you say, it really was quite a challenge, and I'm really thrilled you thought it worked OK. Thanks, so very much.
Tina
PS I'm quivering in my shoes just thinking about writing more prose, but I will give it a go;-)
SundaysChild | July 13, 2011 - 21:21
Thought provoking and moving piece Tina- best of luck to you! x
P.s I agree- you should write more prose :)
Silver Spun Sand | July 13, 2011 - 21:54
Thanks, so very much, Sunday's. I'll try...promise;-)
Tina
skinner_jennifer | August 5, 2011 - 18:06
Congratulations on the cherries Tina,
this was a very well written story,
the cherries were very much deserved.
Jenny.
Rhiannonw | November 17, 2011 - 11:22
I haven't tried to keep up with looking through the prose section, partly due to time constraints, and had missed this until looking in the book. I wanted to say how thoughtfully and sensitively you have been able to open out the subject and present the issues and thoughts and emotions; aswell as writing so well.
Rhiannon
Silver Spun Sand | November 17, 2011 - 12:00
Thanks, so much, for taking the trouble to read this, Riannon. Pleased you got so much from it;-)
Tina
Silver Spun Sand | November 17, 2011 - 12:00
Thanks, so much, for taking the trouble to read this, Riannon. Pleased you got so much from it;-)
Tina
Silver Spun Sand | November 17, 2011 - 12:01
And thanks to you, Jenny. So sorry I am late in replying, but I only just noticed your comment, and it seemed so rude not to apologise.
Tina;-)